Why Pakistan Has 20 Million Crypto Users but Fewer Than 500,000 Stock Market Investors

1. Shallow liquidity

2. Higher volatility

3. Retail panic selling

4. Price manipulation narratives

5. Limited domestic capital depth

It also explains why:

• Mutual funds still allocate only ~15% to equities

• Institutions dominate price discovery

• Retail flows chase momentum, not fundamentals

Markets don’t mature without broad ownership.

The Irony: Pakistan Already Solved Half the Problem

Pakistan successfully:

• Digitized banking

• Scaled mobile wallets

• Normalized IBFT and Raast

• Enabled crypto onramps (informally)

Yet capital markets remained stuck in a 1990s compliance mindset.

This is not a technology problem.
It is a regulatory imagination problem.

What Reforms Would Actually Move the Needle

Forget slogans. These are the real levers:

1. Single Investor Identity

One digital investor ID usable across all brokers.

2. Bank-First KYC

If a bank verifies you, brokers should accept it.

3. Instant Sahulat Accounts

True instant — not “one week later”.

4. Broker Portability

Change brokers without reopening accounts.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

5. Exchange-Level Retail App

PSX must own the front end, not just infrastructure.

6. CGT Rationalization

High friction plus high taxes kills adoption.

Why Crypto Won — And Why Stocks Still Matter More

Crypto attracted users through:

• Speed

• Optionality

• Speculation

• Global narratives

But stocks offer:

• Ownership

• Cash flows

• Dividends

• Governance

• Economic linkage

The tragedy is that Pakistanis are speculating globally while owning nothing locally.

That is a capital formation failure.

Pages: 1 2 3 4