Ghazi Ghori, a 19‑year‑old wicket‑keeper from Lahore, recently posted that “my role model is Tim Paine, but I’ve learned all my wicket‑keeping skills from Saifi Bhai, our head coach & club captain.” The same tweet also notes he “credits Sarfaraz Ahmed for teaching me wicket‑keeping.”1 Within hours, the X‑verse erupted. A string of posts dismissed Paine as a “mediocre talent” and mocked the very idea of a Pakistani idolising an Australian whose Test record is modest at best.2‑5 The clash is not just about taste; it exposes a fault line in how ordinary fans, media pundits and the PCB view role models, talent pipelines and the public cost of misplaced reverence.
Two contradictory narratives
Ghori’s own words are clear and self‑attributed: Tim Paine is his role model, yet the practical lessons come from Saifi Bhai and, according to an image circulating on X, from Sarfaraz Ahmed.6 The image quote – “Tim Paine is my role model in wicket‑keeping but I have learnt from Sarfaraz Ahmed” – is an unattributed graphic, but it repeats Ghori’s claim verbatim.7 By contrast, a wave of criticism from users such as Nilesh Pandit (“Tim Paine is the worst ever Australian wicket‑keeper‑batsman”) and Adarsh Arora (“These chomu Pakistanis are funny”) paints Paine as a symbol of “mediocrity” that Pakistan has “gone wrong” by idolising.3‑4 None of these rebuttals provide performance data; they are pure opinion, yet they shape public sentiment.
Why the choice of role model matters
When a budding cricketer lifts an overseas captain to the status of role model, the message sent to school‑yard players is that success is measured by foreign endorsement, not by home‑grown excellence. Pakistan has a lineage of wicket‑keepers – from Wasim Yousuf to Mohammad Rizwan – whose careers were built on domestic coaching structures. Elevating Paine, whose Test average sits at 30.50 and never scored a century, risks diverting attention from local pathways that need state funding, better facilities, and transparent selection processes.








































