Yet the market is not uniformly barren. Javed Malik reported that a recent Punjab University book festival sold over 200,000 books, and several users praised the bustling Urdu Bazaar in Karachi and the Anarkali Sunday Bazaar in Lahore. These venues, according to Huzaifa Nizam, are “packed with excellent books at comparatively reasonable prices.” Again, these are personal observations; a proper audit of foot traffic, price brackets, and vendor inventories would be needed to confirm the contrast.
The contradiction between a ghostly Liberty store and a thriving street bazaar points to a structural failure. Liberty and its sister chain Readings charge “extremely expensive” prices for the average Pakistani, as reems_1011 put it, yet they “do nothing to make it easier for masses to buy books.” The store’s inventory – described by KD_six as “mostly self‑help slop and coffee‑table accoutrements” – caters to a niche that can afford the markup, while ignoring the bulk of readers who seek affordable literature.
Who bears responsibility? Publishers and importers benefit from high tariffs and weak competition, while the stores themselves refuse to diversify or run meaningful sales. The public cost is clear: families divert money from essential items, literacy suffers, and authors lose royalties because readers turn to pirated copies. To hold anyone accountable we would need three strands of evidence: (1) a breakdown of import duties and GST on books, (2) audited sales data from both high‑end chains and traditional bazaars, and (3) a longitudinal study of reading habits linked to price changes.







































