There is a real industrial base behind this argument. Nasscom’s FY2024 GCC report identified more than 1,700 GCCs, approximately $64.6 billion in revenue and over 1.9 million employees. Those numbers establish scale, not the future relocation of every job now caught in a visa dispute. They also explain Pakistan’s task: buyers choose functioning ecosystems, and patriotism has to become reliable delivery if it is to win contracts.
The insult campaign cannot erase Pakistan’s record
The reply corpus includes repeated demands that Pakistanis stop commenting because they supposedly produce only terrorists, beggars or cleaners. This is national contempt dressed up as an economic argument. Honest discussion of Pakistan’s institutional failures is necessary; a stranger’s slur is not analysis, and dignified service work is not evidence of an entire nation’s inability to engineer.
The June 2026 NFAP study, frequently invoked for its 96 US billion-dollar companies founded or co-founded by Indian immigrants, also lists 10 with Pakistani immigrant founders. The Pakistan Software Export Board reports $3.8 billion in IT and IT-enabled-services exports for FY2024–25. Neither statistic makes Pakistan India’s equal in industrial scale; both demolish the claim that Pakistani technical enterprise does not exist.
The same standard applies to anti-Indian abuse in American replies. Accusations that all Indians are scammers, declarations that an entire nationality deserves hatred, and demands to expel everyone of one origin are not additional payroll evidence. We can document the language and expose its double standards without adopting it. Pakistan’s answer is strongest when it refuses the very collective degradation being used against Pakistanis.
What Pakistan should do next
The commercial opening is not a vacant visa quota waiting to be gifted to Pakistan. It is a buyer’s demand for verifiable talent, dependable infrastructure, transparent subcontracting and accountable delivery. Pakistani firms should offer a defined pilot, disclose who will do the work, demonstrate the product in operation and make compliance part of the sale. A government announcing ambitions while tolerating unreliable connectivity or chaotic payment access is asking exporters to compete with one hand tied.
This continues the argument in Pakistani Freelancers Are Exporters, the distinction between access and commercial execution in Google’s Pakistan Office, and the policy questions raised in Pakistan’s YouTube Income Benchmark. The common issue is whether Pakistan turns capability into durable export receipts instead of exhausting its people with preventable institutional friction.
For technology offices, reliable power belongs inside that delivery promise. A load assessment and appropriately designed backup system can protect operations, but solar equipment alone does not create connectivity, cybersecurity or engineering competence. Businesses assessing office resilience can contact Zorays Solar for an energy consultation grounded in their actual load and operating requirements. That is a practical commercial step, not a claim that energy procurement solves every export problem.
Enough of the bait: Pakistan does not need to celebrate another worker’s uncertainty to demand accountability, and it does not need to swallow abuse to prove sophistication. Share the documented record, ask employers for the recruitment and wage evidence, and ask Pakistan’s own decision-makers for a measurable export plan. The test after this controversy will be simple: who built capacity while everyone else was busy defending a slogan?
Does the PERM suspension end H-1B?
No. The announced action concerns named employers’ labour-certification participation; existing H-1B status is not automatically cancelled by that announcement.
Does India’s H-1B share prove visa fraud?
No. Programme concentration and a fraud rate measure different things. Specific alleged misconduct requires specific evidence.
Does India’s larger IT sector invalidate Pakistani criticism?
No. Industrial scale does not exempt an employer from compliance obligations, and Pakistan’s own export record contradicts claims of zero capability.









































