Background: What Sparked the Controversy?
The controversy emerged after claims circulated online that a Lahore-based doctor, Dr. Ali Zain, was pressured to pay a substantial sum following a patient complaint over an allegedly botched medical procedure. According to statements attributed to the doctor (circulated in Urdu across X/Twitter and WhatsApp groups), he alleged:
“مجھے ایس پی صاحبہ نے کہا کہ آپ ایک گھنٹے میں پہنچیں ورنہ میں آپکے خلاف پرچہ کاٹنے لگی ہوں…
مجھے کہا کہ 10 لاکھ روپیہ دیں… میں نے 10 لاکھ روپے کے 3 چیک دئیے، لیکن ابھی بھی دھمکیوں کا سلسلہ تھم نہیں رہا”
(Translation: I was told to arrive within an hour or a case would be registered against me… I was told to pay ten lakh rupees… I gave three cheques of ten lakh rupees, yet the threats did not stop.)
ASP Naqvi responded through Instagram stories stating that:
-
She was approached privately, not acting in an official police capacity
-
The matter was resolved before police involvement
-
No monetary exchange occurred at her direction
-
She never threatened or coerced anyone
-
Social media commentators should verify facts—or face legal consequences
She further attached photographs with her parents, appealing to personal integrity and moral standing.
